Learning from urban projects: why and how we should unlock the learning potential of urban development projects and programmes

In an earlier post I mentioned that I had been asked to put down some thoughts on learning from urban projects. The thoughts have now been published open source. Link to full text

Forbes Davidson (2022) Learning from urban projects: why and how we should unlock the learning potential of urban development projects and programmes, International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development, DOI: 10.1080/19463138.2022.2042305

The images below show how a project changes over time, but long term monitoring and evaluation and needed to learn the lessons.

Ismailia Hai el Salam 1982
Ismailia Hai el Salam same location 2007

For more information on the Ismailia projects see here for downloads and links , and here for a list of references. Photographs can be accessed here for early stages in the project and here for more recent images.

Here is the abstract:

Urban projects are developed partly to solve local problems but often have wider aims to influence policy and practise. However, there is very little long-term evaluation carried out, and few systematic efforts to link the experience gained in project development and implementation to wider learning and capacity building. I have written this opinion piece based on my experience both in practise in the public and private sectors and in teaching and research. The paper is divided into three parts. First, why urban projects and programmes are important for learning and capacity building. Second, how we learn from projects and the opportunities and barriers to learning. Third, how we could increase learning by explicitly including learning objectives in project planning and evaluation, strengthening links between practice and learning, and improving long-term access to project materials with learning potential.

I would appreciate any feedback and thoughts that you might have.

A small scale “capital investment project” supported by UN-Habitat in Kosovo to improve local conditions and build capacity in local communities and government. 2014

Learning from experience: Daring Cities 2021

Following my post on learning from experience, I recommend accessing the ongoing Daring Cities 2021 conference organized by ICLEI and the City of Bonn. I am not connected to the organizers, but am finding the event highly relevant. In the context of the build-up to COP 26 in Glasgow this online event provides both inspiring […]

Continue reading...

How do we learn from experience?

I was asked to write a think-piece on how we learn from experience. So I have started thinking! The process is ongoing, and I will share it when I have a draft ready. In the meantime, David Allen, former colleague and the founding director of Culpin Planning, is undertaking a major search for materials related […]

Continue reading...

Istanbul and the case of the elusive Urban Development Guidelines

Guidelines on why and how to develop integrated plans and projects were a key output from European countries participating in Habitat II in Istanbul in 1996.  Now, in the build up to Habitat III in 2016 it is useful to ask “What happened?” The story begins in Istanbul.  At the Habitat conference in Istanbul in […]

Continue reading...

World Urban Forum 2014, Medellin – some reflections

  I was asked to add some links to a posting I made at the end of the World Urban Forum (WUF)  in 2012 in Naples.  This was about an inspiring acceptance speech from the former mayor of Medellin, and my hope that the video would be available on YouTube.   Well it is (see […]

Continue reading...

City planning integration – relevance of a good husband?

Poster at city participation meeting, Tenali, Andhra Pradesh

Poster at city participation meeting, Tenali, Andhra Pradesh with former Chief Minister Integrated planning needs  leaders who are able  to think across sectors. What Tony Blair used to call “joined up thinking.” This simple “common sense” skill is often trained/ educated out of professionals.  In the workplace  this process  is completed by the  silo culture of […]

Continue reading...

Integration of urban development in India: any answers?

  The workshop on integrated development in India was valuable, but it would be naïve to expect that one an a half days would give all the answers. It was good to get a range of experiences from India as well as International inputs from Cities Alliance, World Bank, (Capacity Development for Infrastructure in Asia […]

Continue reading...

Integration in planning: Is it worth the effort?

Integrated development is still the “holy grail” of planners, but does it work? How do you make it work? I have just been invited to India to talk about integration in planning at what should be a very interesting workshop. The aim is to set the framework of the second generation of City Development Plans. […]

Continue reading...

Capacity to plan and planning for capacity

Capacity Development Capacity Development is about more than training. It looks at the context needed to support people in their working situation so that they become effective. It also depends on what capacity is needed. The role and nature of urban planning is constantly changing – the normal situation – so developing capacity for this […]

Continue reading...

Elasticity: resilient cities and Black Swans

How to make planning decisions that are clear now and robust in the future? Black swans have been made famous recently through the pertinent book of the same name by Nassim Nicholas Taleb . The main concept is that many of the critical events affecting development are unpredictable.  This doesn’t mean that there is no […]

Continue reading...
%d bloggers like this: